Iran: Why This Time Actually IS Different

Transcript

In case you hadn’t noticed fixing the world is difficult and rather complicated. When you look at Iran and why we went in there it seems to me that if you can stop an abuser you should.

Except the problem sometimes is that the abused don’t want to be helped. They have to want to stop it.

For somebody to be free from an abuser, the desire for that freedom has to come from them. They have to want it. And it gets really complicated when you’re trying to change somebody else’s society and culture. The desire for freedom has to come from the people living in that society.

But just because they want it, doesn’t mean they could do it. Which is why the first thing that abusive governments do is to make sure that people who do want freedom don’t have the means to do it. They take away guns. They take away freedoms—especially freedom of speech.

And that’s very worrisome when you look at what’s happening in most of Europe right now. There is a genuine effort to silence people who dare to question the government. And it’s especially troubling because so many of America’s foundational rights and concepts of those rights originated in England. America would not exist with the freedoms it enshrined, had England not led the way.

Now England is jailing people for things they put on Facebook. Dare to speak out and your government will jail you. Not an armed rebellion. Not actual terrorist attacks. Your opinion. Your opinion can land you in jail. And if you’re not allowed to have an opinion and not allowed to express that opinion, then you really don’t have any freedom at all.

But imagine living in a place like Iran where it’s even worse. Your opinions—speak against the prophet or Allah or refuse the dress code — can and has gotten people killed. And if you’re a woman? It’s far worse than just being killed.

But what is happening right now in Iran can have generational consequences. If it’s done correctly. No endless wars. No imposition of our culture on theirs. That would be just as abusive in its own way. But right now, they have the desire for freedom and the best way to help them pursue that is to get the abuser out of the house. Be there to help if the Iranians want it and do what you can to make sure another abuser doesn’t walk right in the door.

But it’s not going to be easy. It will be difficult. And it will get complicated. But in the end, freedom is worth fighting and dying for.

But there’s also something else here at play that not enough people are talking about that could prove to be the real game changer for the whole of the Middle East.

And we will talk about that with our guest later in the show. But for now I’d like to welcome Brent Sadler, he’s a retired U.S. Navy captain and currently serves as a senior research fellow for naval warfare and advanced technology at the Heritage Foundation —I didn’t even know they had such a thing. He specializes in maritime security and the technologies shaping future naval forces.

Captain and it’s great to talk to you today!

More About this Episode

Now that Iran’s abusive regime is being removed s lot of people are rightfully worried that America has stepped into another Iraq- or Afghanistan-style international quagmire. But forget those “forever war” scripts of the last 20 years. We’re looking at a totally new playbook in the Middle East that skips the nation-building and focuses on a high-stakes, high-tech surge.

This week, we’ll be breaking down the current military chess board and what the next steps look like operationally—including why the old quagmire fears might actually be off the mark this time.

To do this we welcome first time guest Retired Captain, Brent Sadler, who had a 26-year Navy career with numerous operational tours, including on nuclear powered submarines, personal staffs of senior Defense Department leaders, and as a military diplomat in East Asia. As a Senior Research Fellow, Brent’s focus is on maritime security and the technologies shaping our future maritime forces, especially the Navy.

We take a look at the real wildcard. The Iranian people. We discuss seeing signs of an organic shift that hasn’t been possible until now, and we’ll dive into whether regime change is a pipe dream or a pending reality. This isn’t just about regional borders anymore; it’s a massive strategic pivot that’s going to ripple all the way to our competition with China.

And there’s a wild card here that no one seems to be talking about. One that could dramatically change the dynamics of the entire Middle East.

Finally, we’re tackling the “Day After” scenario. If the regime actually buckles, who fills the power vacuum—and how do we ensure we don’t get stuck holding the bag? It’s a realistic, no-nonsense look at the risks, the rewards, and the lessons we (hopefully) finally learned.